
Episode Description
John Leland challenged James Madison over religious liberty. Could the new Constitution leave Americans vulnerable to a national church?
In this episode of America’s Founding Series on The P.A.S. Report Podcast, Professor Nick Giordano reveals the forgotten story of a fearless Baptist preacher who challenged government-backed religion and helped secure support for the First Amendment and Bill of Rights. His fight alongside James Madison and Thomas Jefferson exposes a critical truth about separation of church and state: religious freedom and freedom of conscience are natural rights, not privileges politicians can grant or revoke. Yet even after the First Amendment became law, state governments continued to favor established churches and impose religious taxes for decades.
What You’ll Learn In This Episode:
- John Leland vs. The Original Constitution: How an ordinary Baptist preacher mobilized Virginia citizens, challenged federal power, and pressured James Madison to champion a Bill of Rights.
- The First Amendment & The Ninth Amendment: Why the original Constitution lacked explicit protections against a national church, what the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses prohibit, and why the Ninth Amendment recognizes rights beyond those the Constitution names.
- The Truth About Separation of Church and State: Why Leland and Thomas Jefferson fought to protect religious liberty and freedom of conscience from government coercion, not banish religion from public life.
- The Religious Liberty Battle That Lasted Decades: Why Connecticut and Massachusetts maintained tax-funded religious establishments long after the Bill of Rights took effect in 1791.
- Thomas Jefferson & The 1,200-Pound Mammoth Cheese: The extraordinary political tribute from Cheshire, Massachusetts, and what Leland’s fight reveals about civic responsibility, political accountability, and the defense of liberty.
⭐ Help Keep Authentic American History Alive:
If you believe the sacrifices that built this nation must never be forgotten, follow The P.A.S. Report Podcast, leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and text a link to this episode to 3 or 4 friends and family members right now.
Click play above to listen to the entire episode or you can listen on any podcast platform
00:00 John Leland: The Forgotten Fight for Religious Liberty
02:14 Religious Persecution and Government Control in Colonial Virginia
04:20 James Madison, Thomas Jefferson, and Religious Freedom
06:03 John Leland’s Warning About the Original Constitution
09:26 John Leland, James Madison, and the Fight for a Bill of Rights
13:39 The First Amendment: How Religious Liberty Became Law
18:49 John Leland’s Lessons on Government Power and Individual Rights
John Leland and the First Amendment: The Forgotten Fight for Religious Liberty
You hear politicians and commentators invoke the separation of church and state, but do you know what the Founders actually feared? What happens when government gains the power to dictate religious beliefs, favor certain churches, and punish those who dissent? In this episode of The P.A.S. Report Podcast, we dive deep into the remarkable story of John Leland, the forgotten Baptist preacher who challenged James Madison, helped shape the fight for the First Amendment, and exposed the dangers of government control over religious liberty.
John Leland’s Fight Against Religious Persecution and Government Power
Before the Bill of Rights, colonial governments used taxpayer money to support established churches and punished religious dissenters who challenged their authority. John Leland witnessed religious persecution in Virginia and recognized a dangerous contradiction: Americans fought a revolution for liberty while their own governments restricted freedom of conscience. When the Constitutional Convention produced a new framework of government in 1787, Leland feared that its lack of explicit protections against a national church could threaten the very freedoms Americans had fought to secure. His objections placed him at the center of a constitutional battle that would help define the limits of federal authority.
James Madison, the First Amendment, and the Bill of Rights
The fight for religious freedom brought John Leland into the political orbit of James Madison and Thomas Jefferson, two Founders whose efforts helped transform America’s approach to religious liberty. Leland’s influence among Virginia Baptists gave him political leverage as Madison sought support for the Constitution and his election to the First Congress. Their intertwined stories reveal why the original Constitution lacked a Bill of Rights, why Madison eventually championed constitutional amendments, and why the Ninth Amendment remains essential to the debate over natural rights. The central question was never whether government should grant religious freedom, but whether government possessed the authority to interfere with it in the first place.
Separation of Church and State: The Religious Liberty Fight That Never Ended
The First Amendment did not immediately eliminate government-established religion throughout America. Connecticut maintained its religious establishment until 1818, and Massachusetts continued state-authorized religious support until 1833. Leland’s decades-long campaign demonstrated that constitutional protections mean little without citizens willing to defend them. His unlikely alliance with Jefferson even produced one of the strangest political tributes in American history: a 1,200-pound wheel of cheese delivered to the White House. Yet behind that unusual story lies a powerful lesson about civic responsibility, limited government, and the importance of citizens who refuse to surrender their fundamental liberties.
What You’ll Discover in This Episode
The Constitution’s Religious Liberty Problem: What did John Leland recognize in the original Constitution that alarmed Virginia Baptists?
The Madison-Leland Political Connection: Why did an influential Baptist preacher support Madison, and what role did religious dissenters play in the fight for the Bill of Rights?
The Real Purpose of Church-State Separation: Why did Leland believe government interference posed a threat to religious faith itself?
The Forgotten Fight After 1791: Why did state-supported churches survive for decades after ratification of the First Amendment?
The Lesson Americans Need Today: What can Leland’s story teach Americans about natural rights, government power, and the responsibilities of citizenship?
Subscribe to the podcast and share this link to help more people rediscover the forgotten patriots who built the foundation of the United States.
The P.A.S. Report wants to hear from you. Send your feedback to podcast@pasreport.com. Please leave a 5-star rating and write a review on Apple Podcasts.
Please share this episode with others & on social media.

