Episode Description
What happens when political division turns deadly and neighbors become enemies? Nicholas Herkimer and the Battle of Oriskany reveal one of the bloodiest and most personal battles of the American Revolution.
In this episode of America’s Founding Series on The P.A.S. Report Podcast, Professor Nick Giordano tells the story of Brigadier General Nicholas Herkimer and the nearly 800 Tryon County militiamen who marched toward Fort Stanwix in August 1777. After accusations of cowardice and divided loyalty pushed Herkimer to abandon his plan, his column entered a deadly ambush near Oriskany, where Patriots, Loyalists, Oneida allies, Mohawk warriors, Seneca warriors, former friends, and even relatives fought at close range.
The Battle of Oriskany exposed the civil war within the American Revolution and left the Mohawk Valley scarred for years. As America approaches its 250th anniversary, Herkimer’s story offers a powerful warning about political contempt, civic division, and what can happen when fellow citizens stop seeing one another as neighbors.
What You’ll Learn In This Episode:
- The Road to Fort Stanwix: Why Nicholas Herkimer led nearly 800 Tryon County militiamen through the Mohawk Valley to relieve the American fort
- The Decision That Changed Everything: How accusations of cowardice and Loyalist sympathy pushed Herkimer to abandon his plan and advance
- The Battle of Oriskany: How Loyalist and Native forces trapped Herkimer’s militia in a brutal ravine ambush
- Herkimer Under Fire: How a badly wounded Nicholas Herkimer stayed on the battlefield and helped his men survive the attack
- The Lesson for America Today: Why political contempt can destroy civic bonds and why citizenship requires disagreement without hatred
⭐ Help Keep Authentic American History Alive:
If you believe the sacrifices that built this nation must never be forgotten, follow The P.A.S. Report Podcast, leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and text a link to this episode to 3 or 4 friends and family members right now.
Click play above to listen to the entire episode or you can listen on any podcast platform
00:00 Nicholas Herkimer and the Battle of Oriskany
02:03 When Neighbors Became Enemies in the Mohawk Valley
04:21 The Battle of Oriskany Ambush and Bloody Fighting
07:00 How Herkimer Adapted Under Fire
09:20 Brother Against Brother in the American Revolution
10:44 The Human Cost of the Battle of Oriskany
11:13 What Oriskany Teaches America About Political Division
Nicholas Herkimer and the Battle of Oriskany: What a Divided America Can Learn From 1777
You may think of the American Revolution as Patriots on one side and British redcoats on the other, but the Battle of Oriskany destroys that simple picture. In the Mohawk Valley, neighbors fought neighbors, families split apart, and men who once traded and lived beside one another met in a brutal ambush near Fort Stanwix. At the center stood Nicholas Herkimer, a Patriot militia general whose story reveals both the courage and the danger that emerge when political division turns personal.
In this episode of The P.A.S. Report Podcast, we dive deep into Nicholas Herkimer, the Battle of Oriskany, and the civil conflict that tore through the Mohawk Valley during the American Revolution. This America’s Founding Series episode follows Herkimer from the tense march toward Fort Stanwix to the ravine where nearly 800 Tryon County militiamen entered a devastating ambush. More than a Revolutionary War battle story, Oriskany shows what can happen when political loyalty overwhelms civic bonds and citizens begin to see former neighbors as enemies.
Why Nicholas Herkimer and the Battle of Oriskany Matter
Herkimer’s story carries power because he never fits the mold of a flawless hero. His instincts told him to wait for a signal from Fort Stanwix, but accusations of cowardice and divided loyalty pushed him to advance. The result proved catastrophic. Yet after a musket ball struck his leg and his horse went down beneath him, Herkimer refused to leave the field. From beneath a tree, he rallied his men, helped restore order, and became the steady leader the moment demanded.
How the American Revolution Became a Civil War in the Mohawk Valley
Oriskany exposed a side of the Revolution that many Americans never learn. Patriot settlers, Loyalists, Oneida allies, Mohawk warriors, Seneca warriors, friends, relatives, and former neighbors all found themselves on opposing sides. The Mohawk Valley had spent years under pressure from political suspicion, divided loyalties, property seizures, exile, and resentment. By August 1777, those fractures had moved from homes and communities onto the battlefield.
What the Battle of Oriskany Can Teach America Today
The deeper lesson reaches beyond military history. Free societies depend on vigorous disagreement, but they also depend on citizens who still recognize one another as members of the same political community. Oriskany shows the danger that follows when disagreement turns into contempt and contempt hardens into hatred. Nicholas Herkimer’s story forces a difficult question for modern America: if citizens increasingly treat dissenters as enemies rather than neighbors, why should anyone assume that whatever comes next will prove better than what exists now?
Questions the Full Episode Answers
- Why did Herkimer abandon his original plan and march toward the ambush?
- How did accusations of cowardice change the course of the Battle of Oriskany?
- What happened after Herkimer suffered a severe leg wound?
- Why did former friends, relatives, Patriots, Loyalists, and Native allies fight one another at such close range?
- What warning does Oriskany offer Americans as the nation hits its 250th anniversary?
Subscribe to the podcast and share this link to help more people rediscover the forgotten patriots who built the foundation of the United States.
The P.A.S. Report wants to hear from you. Send your feedback to podcast@pasreport.com. Please leave a 5-star rating and write a review on Apple Podcasts.
Please share this episode with others & on social media.